Paintball Benny is the older brother and arch-rival of Paintball Mike and the leader of the 7th grade paintballers. According to J.P., he is the reason the paintball war between the 6th and 7th graders, as he shot Mike in the "noo-noo".
Paintball Benny looks very similar to his brother, having blond hair and wearing an army hat and eyepatch, but he is taller and has freckles. He also wears a grayish-brown shirt, brown pants, and dark brown combat boots. His right eyebrow is a line of green paint, meaning he either got paint on it during battle, or he is missing that eyebrow and painted himself a new one.